Ask an expert

Concept demo. Umbrello is not an insurer or broker. Plans, insurers and prices are made up.

Skip to content
Underwriter comparison

Insurers, compared honestly.

Claims settlement percentages, actual days to pay, and consumer grievance rates compared side by side.

Settlement Rate

Claims settled (%)

Kestrel General Insurance (fictional)97.2%
Saffron Mutual General (fictional)98.1%
Banyan Assure (fictional)95.8%
Peakline General (fictional)93.5%
Tidewater Health (fictional)92.4%
Harbour Life (fictional)99.1%
Turnaround Speed

Average days to settle

Kestrel General Insurance (fictional)6 days
Saffron Mutual General (fictional)5 days
Banyan Assure (fictional)8 days
Peakline General (fictional)10 days
Tidewater Health (fictional)9 days
Harbour Life (fictional)12 days
Customer Grievances

Complaints per 10,000

Kestrel General Insurance (fictional)18
Saffron Mutual General (fictional)12
Banyan Assure (fictional)26
Peakline General (fictional)41
Tidewater Health (fictional)22
Harbour Life (fictional)9

All six underwriters compared

InsurerLines offeredClaims settledAvg turnaroundComplaints / 10kNetwork partners
Kestrel General Insurance (fictional)
car, bike, health, term97.2%6 days186200 garages · 8400 hospitals
Saffron Mutual General (fictional)
car, bike98.1%5 days127400 garages · 4500 hospitals
Banyan Assure (fictional)
car, bike95.8%8 days264900 garages · 4500 hospitals
Peakline General (fictional)
car, bike, health93.5%10 days413800 garages · 5100 hospitals
Tidewater Health (fictional)
health92.4%9 days221200 garages · 11200 hospitals
Harbour Life (fictional)
term99.1%12 days91200 garages · 4500 hospitals
Methodology: Numbers are made up for this concept. A real version would use each insurer's public disclosures and annual regulatory filings.